vimeomontage

Friday, June 11, 2010

Tanah Merah (Site 8) - 06June2010

Pics from Site 8 across from the Tanah Merah Ferry Terminal


tanah merah sitemap
satellite map view


The Tanah Merah shore is (or rather was) a beautiful shore reclaimed from the sea. The seawalls or breakwaters form a lagoon with the shore. Various fish and other organisms hide in the breakwater during the day and appear once the sky gets dark.
2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_02
However, the lagoons may also encourage a large portion of marine trash to get stuck on the shore. Sadly, nearby coastal communities are reckless and careless being ignorant of the damage they case when they dispose of plastic material into the sea. 'Out of sight is out of mind' for all the contributors.
2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_wide_trash

2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_16

2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_04

2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_07

Local fishermen also leave behind a lot of trash. The pic below shows a mini cyalum stick. This is commonly used by fishermen as an indiator on their fishing rods at night when it has caught something. An important ingredient of this tool is cyanide. Once the plastic tube is compromised, the cyano compounds will flow out as well.

2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_10
Fishermen also carelessly dispose of their bags and food containers.
2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_09



2010June06_Tanah Merah Site 8_14

Site 8 canal view
If we do not treasure what we have inherited, then what can we give those who come after us?

Monday, June 7, 2010

Tanah Merah (Site 9) - 06June2010



3 kids playing on the oil-stained rocks. Notice the reddish tinge on the rocks. At some point, the kids go barefoot. The kids were well soaked with the water from the lagoon despite the distinct smell of crude oil lingering from the oil soaked rocks. They came with some adults who were off fishing elsewhere in the lagoon.

Tanah Merah (Site 10) - 06June2010



06June2010 - oiled stained trash mixed with unstained trash collected in a corner against a well-stained seawall barrier....waiting for the next high tide to sweep them further along the coast or out to sea.



06June2010- Clumping of residual crude oil in the pool near the SAF Yacht Club. The seawall and surrounding rocks were heavily stained by the crude oil slick over an extended period of time.



06June2010 - residual clumps of crude still on tanah merah shores

Tanah Merah CleanUp - 05June2010

tanah merah singapore
Map

Saturday 05 June2010 - a motley crew of volunteers met, many meeting each other for the first time, to do what they could for a troubled shore...covered with crude oil from over the past weekend. The call for volunteers was made via Facebook merely 24 hours before and 19 volunteers responded all eager to help do their bit to help protect and conserve a quiet secluded Singapore shore long since reclaimed from the sea.

2010June05_Tanah Merah_CleanUp_01

Initial efforts were hampered by rain and lightning and the Team had to wait out the weather for about an hour. Once the thunder had rumbled on and the lightning was distant enough, the team gleefully made their way to shore in the rain which eventually gave way to a light drizzle. A cool strong wind made everyone feel the chill. The plus point of the chilly wind was that the strong smell of

2010June05_Tanah Merah_CleanUp_02
the crude oil on the shore was partly replaced with fresh sea air making the necessary breathing somewhat tolerable.

2010June05_Tanah Merah_CleanUp_03
ML, an NUS grad student uses her umbrella for shelter whilst picking up oil-soiled trash from an oil soaked shore.

The trash bags fluttering in the wind...it took a few moments to get used to the wind's effect on opened trash bags which wanted to fly away from their duty... but the wind was quickly conquered with a few handfuls of readily available trash on the shore. Orientated into the wind at the right angle, one could keep the bag open with one hand whilst throwing in trash with the other.

Focusing on material coated with crude oil such as plastic bottles, plastic bags, styrofoam, and other light material, 85 bags worth of flotsam was collected in about 2 hours from about 500m of shore not forgetting two spades and some soiled absorbent booms left behind by CleanUp contract workers from earlier in the week when the first slick patch hit the Tanah Merah coast.

There was a good amount of plastic bags on the lower shore which were covered with crude oil and these had turned a dark brown. What was unexpected was that these plastic bags tore like water-soaked paper upon being pulled from the sand....disturbing signs that the crude oil was eating away at the plastic slowly dissolving what would normally not degrade for eons. Disturbing because the dissolved plastic would be seeping into the ecosystem. As to where it would all end up is anyone's guess but the food chain would definitely pick some of the material.

It seems that no one had expected a second patch to wash ashore. Despite satellite imagery and patrol boats, no one knew of (or if they knew, was bothered by) the second slick patch ... until it was already almost on the shore.

Why were preventive measures not taken to contain this second slick before it reached the Tanah Merah shore?



2010June05_Tanah Merah_CleanUp_04
Two volunteer RJC students do their bit buffetted by the strong cold wind and rain.

Crude oil soaked plastic bags lying on the lower shore tore readily upon a slight pull indicating that the crude oil was eating away at the plastic bags.....which could only mean that the plastic was being dissolved away into the ecosystem. Not a good thing.

2010June05_Tanah Merah_CleanUp_06
AK(at right), an exchange student from the US helping out at Tanah Merah with a friend, PCF.

Despite the 85 bags (and not forgetting the numerous bags cleared by the contract workers from the National Environment Agency from the far end of the same shore), only a small portion of the visible shoreline was cleaned up. The effects of the CleanUp can be said to have a negligible effect on the overall condition of the shore as the now cake-like sand-tar mixture will likely continue to ooze oil for a very long time to come.


The clip below shows the far end of the same shore the next day on Sunday 06June2010 with accumulations of flotsam, a huge quantity of it plastic. Whilst the natural woody material will biodegrade, the plastic will not and will continue to cover the shore or get eventually pulled out by the tides to journey to other far shores in a neverending repeating tour.


Where does all this plastic come from?

The second slick which affected the Tanah Merah shore was not-prepared for and it stuck to all the available surfaces such as the seawall, sandy shore and the various flotsam on the shore. Whilst the flotsam can be removed, the crude oil which had long since soaked into the sand and formed chocolate-cake like patches looks set to persist for a very long time unless the same is dug out. Meanwhile, a visible oily sheen can be seen at each low tide accumulating in the lagoon formed by the breakwater. Perhaps time and tide will clear the oil away in due course.

Sunday, May 30, 2010

Singapore Oil Spill - Tanah Merah Slick - 30May2010

Went out to Tanah Merah in the afternoon and the acrid smell of the oil spill filled the air near the PUB waste water treatment works. The location was about midway between SAF Yacht Club and Tanah Merah Ferry Terminal.

There was a lot of sludge which had accumulated in the drainage canal leading out to the sea. I lifted one of the grilles to get a look at the sludge which kept thrashing about as the waves moved along the canal from the shore opening.



Despite the absorbent booms (now a deep chocolate colour) which had been placed at certain points in the canal, it seemed as if the booms were useless against the continual onslaught of the waves.
Shortly thereafter, a huge tank truck drove up alongside the canal. It had the words 'Vacuum Tanker' on the rear. The workers quickly set up the vacuum hose and slowly lowered it into the drain. The idea was to suck up all the sludge...harder than it seems...as they did not want seawater as well...only sludge...this meant that the hose had to be kept at the surface and could not go too much below the surface. This was very difficult with the constant wave action sloshing around the sludge in the drainage chamber. The system was probably not designed to handle wave action as the workers could only momentarily suck up sludge in between the ups and downs of the waves in the drainage chamber.


Singapore Oil Spill - Chek Jawa CleanUp - 29May2010

Got to Ubin just before the press gang reached there at about 1pm. Met up with Hang Chong, Alyce and some other hardy volunteers at the NParks' Ubin Volunteer Hub. They had spent the morning braving the crude on the CJ shore. After some short interviews, the press gang headed out to CJ along with NUS' Prof. Peter Ng, Sivasothi N. and senior NParks officers.

CJ was a buzz of activity. There were loads of Indian and Bangladeshi workers in orange and yellow worksuits, hardhats and gloves. Carrying, transporting, heaving, pushing white plastic bags of soiled rags and dirty sand used or collected from the CJ shore. Some, exhausted, were taking a break under the shade of the trees, recharging themselves for more work when the tide went down after an afternoon high.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_004

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_007

The workers were from two companies activated apparently by MPA/NEA/NParks. 107 of them were from Kim Eng Shipyard and about 20 were from Lian Shing ?. The Lian Shing 20 were 'experienced' at oil slick duties having spent the previous day fighting the worst of the crude.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_008
Not having seen what the slick at CJ had been like the previous day, it was unsettling enough to see what remained after one day. Absorbent booms, some long since spent (i.e dark brown), lined some parts of the shore near the boardwalk section closest to House #1. There was still a very visible thick sheen on the surface of the water and the water looked deceptively inviting apart from the crude smell of crude.

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_026

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_020

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_018

At certain parts, a thick brown sludge could be seen in patches and there were scattered blobs all over.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_015

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_013

No dead fish or other sick looking animals seen on the surface. Bearing in mind that this was about 24 hours after the slick stuck CJ at a time when the tide was at its highest the previous day, perhaps all the dead creatures were on the bottom or had joined the flow of the ebbing tide away from the shore. (The low tide later that evening did not show any dead creatures too.)

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_043

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_041

There were two boats (Bridgewater & Camelia) further out about 150m from the boardwalk and they had attached between them a long floating boom. The boats were about 300 or 400m apart and it looked like the float was to prevent any further slick from impacting the CJ shore.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_010

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_036

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_033

As usual with the waters around CJ, there was marine litter floating in on the surface. This time, all of it had crude oil all over. These items will eventually be pushed by the waves on to the shore and into the mangrove areas.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_056

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_060

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_027

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_045

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_050

Walking along the boardwalk, it was easy to spot the crude residue on the lower branches and leaves of the mangrove trees. Not a palatable sight for tree lovers. The brown goo stuck to the leaves despite the waves.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_052

Some ketapang tree (Sea Almond) leaves seemed to have been bleached of chlorophyll. However, these were isolated leaves and it may be that the cause of the discoloration was something else apart from the crude or the chemical dispersants used.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_068

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_057

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_058

The usual congregations of mudskippers were missing from the granite rocks in the water near the boardwalk. Only a few were seen seeming to patiently wait for the tide to subside. They did not seem distressed although there were much fewer numbers seen on the rocks. Prof Peter Ng mentioned that mudskippers are one of the more resilient coastal species which should enable them to ride out the slick avoiding any immediate effects...however, long term effects may however tell a different story. Hopefully we do not see any dead dugongs, sea otters, sea kraits or shore birds at CJ as a result of the slick.

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_054

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_059

The mangrove trees and their wide reaching roots had already trapped some contaminated flotsam items. The workers were busy scraping the sand and wiping sludge covered roots which were within reach. Picking up litter was not topmost on the instruction list although some sludge covered items were removed with the contaminated top-sand.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_087

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_103

Mangrove tree roots provided a natural place for accumulations of crude sludge.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_099

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_101

There was a particular short bay at the northern part of CJ which seemed to be where the slick hit the shore...ground zero. The other side of the mangrove clump was free of crude.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_104

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_105

A few metres further up beyond the clump of mangroves (near a huge truck tire embedded in the sand), there was little sign of any sludge residue at all. There was a group of workers busy clearing the sand higher up the shore. However, lower down near the water line, each wave brought more brown goo onto the sand. One worker tried dragging his shovel to clear the brown goo but it got replaced almost immediately with more goo with each wave. He quickly abandoned the idea.

Luckily, Singapore's new favourite in demand item that weekend, the giant white absorbent boom tampon was quickly requested and the workers carried the various bundles the 400m distance from the pickup point near the mid-point of the boardwalk to the northern shore. Several 'tampons' were lined up over about 100m and placed interconnected along the Northern shore towards the boardwalk area. The ends were tied down to the nearby mangrove trees in the hope that the continuous booms would soak up the residual sludge and crude particles. I did not think these would have much effect. (but I was surprised 24 hours later when a visit the next day showed that the booms did have a good amount of success).

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_134

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_135

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_136

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_138

Some of the workers were busy manually wiping the lower sections of the mangrove tree roots. This seemed like a very good idea but the gianormous task of wiping each and every mangrove root free of the sludge is an equally mindboggling task as each tree had somewhere between 20 to 40 roots shoots and many of these were intertwined and unreachable. Some workers continued to use their gloves but others had resorted to using their bare hands to hold the rags.

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_114

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_123

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_121
Given the numerous trees within a short 50m stretch, it was certain that they would not finish their task that day let alone the weekend.

The workers stopped work at about 6.00pm but had to clear the collected bags and their tools for the next day's cleanup. I was surprised that there was no night cleanup crew. This was an 'office hours' only cleanup eventhough it was a low-tide evening.


With the tide almost at it's lowest in the early evening, some herons flew in to feed. They did not seem bothered by the oily sheen on the water although I did not see any bird attempt to strike at a fish in the water. They were looking but did not see. Perhaps the oily sheen prevented the birds from seeing past the surface. They would go hungry that evening.

2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_139

The mudskippers were less active than they normally were and there were fewer of them out.

The sand bubbler crabs were slowly appearing from their burrows.
2010May29_Chek Jawa_OilSpill_132a
I wonder how these crabs would fare over the next few weeks as their eating habits necessitate licking the grains of sand which will eventually be interspersed with crude oil micro-clumps due to the effects of the chemical dispersants used. Time till tell....but no one had ever paid any attention to the tiny sand bubbler crabs at Chek Jawa. If they do die out because of the slick, how long will it take for new crabs to take their place? And will this have an chain effect on the other parts of the Chek Jawa ecosystems?